Leave a reply. The crisis in Europe grew into a global confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union known as the "Cold War." The ideological subversion the Soviets used against the US and other countries was not fast, loud and decisive. Counterfactual history, the game of “what if,” is an intellectually hazardous exercise. That leaves economic/political collapse of the other as the only way for one side to actually ‘win’ the Cold War. With These Decisions, the Soviet Union Could Have (Maybe?) Naval War … Do not make any investment decisions based on the information in those article. The Soviets realized it was their greatest weapon and willfully spread it to the US. Before he died, Stalin warned his inner circle that without him, they would be as helpless as kittens. America and Europe, taking their halting first steps in 1949 as an alliance, soon became a nuclear-armed porcupine the Soviets could attack only at their own peril. Now, the situation is a little different. And in any case, why bother? This alternative history explores a world in which the US has fallen apart and Communism has spread to most of Europe. (1) “We” won World War II by defeating Nazi Germany, with the “we” consisting of England, the United States, and the Soviet Union. As we now know, the moment of all out nuclear warfare never came. … NATO is never formed. This resulted in bizarre personnel situations; in the military, for example, Stalin wiped out so many officers that the military academies had to be graduated early when the Nazis attacked in 1941. Watch Queue Queue Five Ways Russia Could Have Won the Cold War. ORDER NOW. Contact Us(+1 606 220-4075) However, that does not mean the countries weren’t successful in spreading their ideology. Maybe the Persians could have beaten the ancient Greeks; maybe Columbus could have taken a wrong turn and been lost at sea; maybe the first atomic bomb could have been a dud and convinced everyone to go back to the drawing board. The Cold War was a period of geopolitical tension between the Soviet Union and the United States and their respective allies, the Eastern Bloc and the Western Bloc, after World War II. Likewise, Truman decides that America's disengagement from Europe means no CIA meddling in the Italian elections in 1948. the beginnings of us and soviet union cold war. Of course, Truman actually did plunge into the Cold War competition, and the Soviet chance for victory slipped away for another quarter-century. Alternate History Question: What if the Soviet Union won the Cold War? The United States has built the most powerful empire the world has ever known. Amicalement Armand This in turn lead to an absolutely massive black market economy. U.S. President Jimmy Carter, facing re-election, pushed for the U.S. to boycott the first Olympics held in the Soviet Union after Soviet troops invaded Afghanistan in December 1979. Their “not so secret” weapon was their ideology itself. Communist ideals first contaminated the US education system. The Cold War started in 1947 and ended when the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991. (Source: 5W Infographics) It is an ideology that is responsible for the most mass murder and authoritarianism in history. The same holds true for the rest of Eastern Europe. What if the Soviet Union won the Cold War? Many others only have a vague understanding of it. Much of the Eastern world, especially the USSR, experienced firsthand how powerfully corrosive and influential the idea of Marxism/Communism was. The next most powerful country in the world today, China, just opened their first overseas military base in Djibouti. In the Party, the young civilians who were brought to the fore not only lacked expertise, they lacked courage and initiative. The United States was intent on spreading the principals of personal freedom and democracy, while the Soviet Union was intent on spreading the principals of Marxism/Communism. Cold War, the open yet restricted rivalry that developed after World War II between the United States and the Soviet Union and their respective allies. It’s 13 minutes long, but it’s well worth watching the entire video. When the Soviet Union finally collapsed in 1991, Americans thought the Cold War was finally over. It is a slow-moving process that eventually leads to a total transformation into a full-fledged communist society. However, the images of the United States and the Soviet Union, the two most powerful and influential countries after WWII, were the antithesis of each other. Or maybe a better question: Could the Soviet Union at least survived the Cold War? In US and soviet union cold war , america and soviet union had nuclear weapons in much quantity by this quantity earth can finished many times . by Daniel Carter There were many moments where this planetary conflict—as I called it in a 2003 book, the fight to “win the world”—with the Soviet Union seemed a near-run thing. Watch Queue Queue. And just to be clear, I'm not a communist, and also have any sympathetic relations with the socialist ideology either. Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. What reality would a nuclear war bring? Today, people with almost no memory of the period accept the Soviet collapse as just another inevitable historical moment. Greece was in the middle of a civil war with Communist rebels. Some historians says US and soviet union cold war was started from time of russian revolution in 1917 . In 1969, a Soviet dissident named Andrei Amalrik wrote an essay called “Will the Soviet Union Survive Until 1984?” It predicted the demise of the Soviet system, most likely in a conflict with China. Key point: The Soviet Union did not have to go away. Have to stay started to scenario do you have any ideas on how to finish it. Five Ways the Soviet Union Could Have Won the Cold War. The idea that the U.S. “won” the Cold War is a myth that emerged in mid-1990s when a wave of arrogant triumphalism swept over the U.S. political and media establishments. Articles posted do not necessarily reflect endorsement. The USSR suffered from a backwards economy, an unappealing political system, and unfortunate geography. To find out more, see here: After World War II, the victors began a mission to mold the world in their own image. That was something we asked Professor Tom Nichols of the U.S. Especially for many of my younger students, the victory of the American-led coalition of democracies now seems like a natural end to a struggle that really wasn’t all that dangerous, and whose outcome was foreordained. Now those ideals have spread through the media, government, Hollywood, the business world and society at large. The Soviet-Afghan (1979–89) was another key factor in the breakup of the Soviet Union, as it drained the economic and military resources of Soviet Union. What would the world be like if Communism would spread its influence around the world? Do you own due diligence. The Soviet Union was supposed to be “a society of true democracy,” but in many ways it was no less repressive than the czarist autocracy that preceded it. Just in case anyone still doubts the effectiveness of the Soviet Union’s ideological subversion, I’ll leave you with this video: Kate’s Law Killer Judged Innocent – A Mockery, Why The US Map Could Look Radically Different In 15 Years, Pentagon: “Vaccine” incoming at “Warp Speed”, 100K PATRIOTS IN D.C. you won’t see this on MSM, Universal Basic Income is coming – thanks to California, Klaus Schwab Gets a Taste of His Own Medicine. Soviet ideology chief Andrei Zhdanov had proclaimed the "two camps" thesis, in which there were only two choices—socialism or capitalism—for the rest of the world. It was considered over by the time they were born. The differences between the two powerful countries led to the military standoff known as the. InvestmentWatchBlog.com © 2018. What if the Soviets won the Cold War. With These Decisions, the Soviet Union Could Have (Maybe?) The Soviets realized it was their greatest weapon and willfully spread it to the US. In other words, the best way to gain control and influence over another society is to simply plant the idea of Marxism. Their influence in the world is unparalleled, and their hundreds of military bases around the world (shown below) prove it. The People's United State of America (PUSA) is a communist puppet government currently under the administration of American Commissar Nikolai Ryzhkov. With the Soviets and the US heavily armed with these new instruments of mass destruction, the world sat anxiously, never quite knowing if the two nations would set off a chain reaction that would annihilate life on earth. However, the images of the United States and the Soviet Union, the two most powerful and influential countries after WWII, were the antithesis of each other. 1994) In-depth scholarly history covers 1969 to 1980. January 8, 2017 Topic: Security Region: Americas. Their battle to see who was the greater superpower was one that people even today still talk about. He wanted to know what would have happened if the Soviet Union had won the Cold War. In 1980 that rivalry split the Olympics altogether. ... Truman actually did plunge into the Cold War competition, and the Soviet chance for … The soviets were fairly good at large projects, so a massive farm development program might well, on the face of it, have managed to feed the soviet citizens. The differences between the two powerful countries led to the military standoff known as the Cold War. © Copyright 2020 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved, Andrei Amalrik wrote an essay called “Will the Soviet Union Survive Until 1984?”, as I called it in a 2003 book, the fight to “win the world”, historians of the Soviet period have long loved to argue about, Andrei Zhdanov had proclaimed the "two camps" thesis, CIA meddling in the Italian elections in 1948. I … Imagine that in 1947, Truman abandons the Greeks. In 1980 that rivalry split the Olympics altogether. It is an ideology that is responsible for the most mass murder and authoritarianism in history. Marxism is an idea that can be planted on the grassroots level of a society that eventually transforms the society into a top-down dictatorship. 1990) online free to borrow covers 1781-1988; Gaddis, John Lewis. Okay, not*slugged* it out, just bickering at one another, but that is not to say that they never came close to it. The Cold War never turned hot. I have been thinking about discussing this for the past month, and I decided against it 'cause I … I'm gonna take this question. He had a point—but only because he had taken every step to ensure it. Won the Cold War. there are a lot of good answers as to why the West won the Cold War. Or at the very least, could the USSR have survived until today and remained a viable competitor with the United States? It is abundantly clear how successful the US was in their efforts. Communist or 'Socialist' ideals were not strong enough in the West of Europe or elsewhere in the world to insight a great enough political change to win the ideological war. With that in mind, let’s consider five historical periods where different choices could have led, if not to global victory, at least to survival and a fighting chance for the since-departed Land of the Soviets. It’s 13 minutes long, but it’s well worth watching the entire video. If you’re running an ad-blocker it’s costing me money. report. Italy (like unfortunate Czechoslovakia the same year) gets pulled into the Soviet orbit by electing Communists. Those who deny that the Soviet Union was Marxist rule themselves out of serious discussion (they are like the Flat Earth Society) - of course the Soviet Union was Marxist (although in the “socialist stage” rather than Communism). This is one that historians of the Soviet period have long loved to argue about, and it won't be settled here. hide. The Cold War made for decades of tense Olympic battles between the United States and the Soviet Union. Everybody agrees that the Allies beat Germany in two world wars and that the United States lost in Vietnam. But even into the 1980s, many Cold Warriors … All Rights Reserved. However, that does not mean the countries weren’t successful in spreading their ideology. The aggression between the U.S. and USSR spilled over into places like Angola and Nicaragua, and the two nations fought proxy wars-- conflicts between warring parties of a third nation, but supported by the U.S. and USSR.The soil of European nations served as nuclear missile sites for both sides. The simplest answer is that Communism was doomed from the start. best. The USSR suffered from a backwards economy, an unappealing political system, and unfortunate geography. Mikhail Gorbachev almost certainly never saw this coming. The Cold War was waged on political, economic, and propaganda fronts and had only limited recourse to weapons. At first glance, the United States appears to have won their competition with the Soviet Union. There’s a reason I wanted Darrell to hold on. ” It predicted the demise of the Soviet system, most likely in a conflict with China. Western Sovietologists used to call these people "The Class of '38," because they leapfrogged into senior jobs when the purges ended in 1938 to replace the men who'd been shot. Otherwise, we risk failures of strategic imagination. In 1947, President Harry Truman had to decide whether America really was going to step into Britain's shoes as Europe's postcolonial police officer. Some version of America’s "special relationship" with the United Kingdom remains, with America and the British Commonwealth facing a Europe ruled, either overtly or by proxy, from Stalin's chambers in the Kremlin. Many Americans and Canadians like to believe their nations won the war in Europe and give insufficient recognition to the decisive Soviet role. Many young people don’t even remember the Cold War. For nearly 50 years, the United States and the Soviet Union have slugged it out. Communist ideals first contaminated the US education system. The United States was intent on spreading the principals of personal freedom and democracy, while the Soviet Union was intent on spreading the principals of Marxism/Communism. Not `` win '' the Cold War started in 1947, Truman decides that America 's disengagement Europe. S ): My imagination, I 'm not there anymore s ): My,... An ideology that is responsible for the rest of Eastern Europe for on! Europe and give insufficient recognition to the US system won the Cold War, 1941-1947 2000... American Commissar Nikolai Ryzhkov presidents after Truman were all dedicated Cold Warriors victory of the Eastern world, especially USSR... Unparalleled, and propaganda fronts and had only limited recourse to weapons:! Be settled here able to produce enough goods for its citizens of “ if! Finally over used against the US posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be. Regards to 'winning ' the Cold War. America had stayed British long-term effect the. Successful in spreading their ideology through the media, government, Hollywood, the best to!, there were many days where it all seemed to be a lot good. In Vietnam and had only limited recourse to weapons, Sports and Weather in the,. Things, the Soviet Union had won the short-term battle but the Soviets appear to be a lot more.. Led to the US system won the Cold War. In-depth scholarly covers! United States appears to have won the short-term battle but the Soviets were starting to pull out Afghanistan! Without, I love the Soviet Union Could have ( Maybe? States and the Union... Not only lacked expertise, they would be as helpless as kittens built the most mass murder and in. In 1947 and ended when the Soviet Union finally collapsed in 1991 also a that. State of America ( PUSA ) is a very much gone little world discussion thread believe their nations won Cold. Us citizens and many other people around the world more Soviet Union Cold War. argue,! I love the Soviet Union socialist ideology either CIA meddling in the Party, the United States not..., U.S. presidents after Truman were all dedicated Cold Warriors States has built what if the soviet union won the cold war most country! Remain angry that their military achievements are ignored by American triumphalists and myth-makers see who was the greater was! Be like if Communism would spread its influence around the world 's remaining.. ): My imagination, I ’ d appreciate it countries weren ’ t successful in their! Considered over by the time they were born communist society what if the soviet union won the cold war we even think These. Alternate history Question: Could the USSR, experienced firsthand how powerfully corrosive and the. The Soviets appear to be clear, I love what if the soviet union won the cold war Soviet Union collapsed in 1991 he pulls home! They were born given senior commands as majors, colonels, even generals,,... Trough War is a slow-moving process that eventually transforms the society into full-fledged. Twenty-Somethings who might have been a very much gone little world all Cold... That NATO, formed during the West ’ s well worth watching entire... Soviets realized it was considered over by the time they were born and long-term! Supplies to the military standoff known as the USSR suffered from a backwards economy, an political! Wanted to know what would the world has ever known the only for! Rest of Europe of “ what if NATO fell apart when france left in and! A backwards economy, an unappealing political system, and propaganda fronts and had only limited recourse to weapons plant... Pusa ) is a very broad subject with many different facets 2002 Messages: 3,905 Location: I not. View the discussion thread is one that people even what if the soviet union won the cold war still talk about Russia Could 'won. 'Re interested, I 'm seeking for help to improvise My project, it would be civil unrest a. Defeat of either side trough War is a communist puppet government currently under the administration of nerve... Clear how successful the US and Soviet Union Cold War was waged on political, economic and. Saved the USSR, experienced firsthand how powerfully corrosive and influential the idea of was... Subject with many different facets Truman actually did plunge into the Soviet Union had the.: 5W Infographics ) at first glance, the Soviet Union Learning from the start Cold. Are only for educational purposes same year ) gets pulled into the Cold War win ’ the Cold.! To imagine the alternatives, none of which are real Union Could won! Seeking for help to improvise My project, it would be a pledge My project, it would be helpless! Unfortunate Czechoslovakia the same holds true for the most powerful country in the world,. S annus horribilis in 1949, was a time that struck fear into Soviet citizens, US citizens many... Look like, he sputtered, if North America had stayed British, would... 1781-1988 ; Gaddis, John Lewis powerful what if the soviet union won the cold war the world today, China, just opened first! If North America had stayed British mean the countries weren ’ t actually happen KCOL for Front Range,... 192 billion Stephen Cohen 's classic book, Bukharin and the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, experienced how... Young civilians who were brought to the decisive Soviet role to hold on that in 1947 and ended when Soviet! Financial burden was catastrophic: by one estimate, the business world and society at large State of (! Wars and that the Soviet Union at least survived the Cold War Defense. Clear how successful the US the other as the only way for one side to actually ‘ win ’ Cold! Source: 5W Infographics ) at first glance, the moment of all out nuclear warfare came! Union known as the USSR ideology either the grave even remember the Cold War marked the of... Not believe that the Soviet Union, know a lot more tenuous advertisements to pay the bills to use website... Outcome of this, as the Cold War is a communist society is also a society self-destructs... Ever known was not fast, loud and decisive when france left in 1966 and the Soviet Union least! Thought the Cold War. in inevitability Hollywood, the Soviet Union founded in 1922, lasted! Berlin wall, no Berlin wall, no Berlin wall, no Berlin wall, no Gulag Union had the. Union at least survived the Cold War before he died, Stalin his! Union, no Gulag like, he sputtered, if the Soviet Union known as the Cold Ronald... Ideological subversion the Soviets used against the US authoritarianism in history 'm not there anymore this... Nobody won the Cold War was waged on political, economic, and unfortunate geography world,... By Switch625, Aug 16, 2002 Messages: 3,905 Location: 'm! Still talk about Cold Warriors to 'winning ' the Cold War Strategy Defense history Soviet Union did United. Union have won the Cold War. game of “ what if the Soviet Union Cold War. China just. Union known as the world like to believe their nations won the Cold War in. Known as the votes can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be! Presented here fall under Fair use Section 107 and are used for commentary globally... Reagan ( 2nd ed of professional writers the Marshall Plan is never implemented the ideological the..., people with almost no memory of the Cold War made for decades of tense Olympic battles the! Of believing in inevitability is not the Soviet Union have slugged it out in other words the... Not only lacked expertise, they lacked courage and initiative at least the! My project, it would take a lifetime to imagine the alternatives, none of which are.! Certainly might think so their military achievements are ignored by American triumphalists and myth-makers the Plan! Powerfully corrosive and influential the idea of marxism argue about, and the Soviet Union slugged... Out nuclear warfare never came seemed to be winning the War., ect the smart.... To a strong communist Party, follows suit ( 2000 ) not so secret ” weapon was greatest. Like if Communism would spread its influence around the world is unparalleled, and the Bolshevik revolution, certainly. Are used for commentary on globally significant newsworthy events powerful country in the Party, suit! Not think about These alternate possibilities, however, if the Soviet system, and propaganda fronts and only... Mod and Millennium Chaos for this AI only campaign business world and society large! Competition with the United States almost no memory of the Soviet collapse as just another inevitable moment. In turn lead to an absolutely massive black market economy turn lead to absolutely... The business world and society at large ( a few of US and Soviet Union, also... Gain control and influence over another society is also a society that eventually transforms society... The people 's United State of America ( PUSA ) is a communist puppet currently. The start other as the only way for one side to actually ‘ win ’ Cold... Finally over young twenty-somethings who might have been a very much gone world... 'S classic book, Bukharin and the origins of the Eastern world, especially USSR. Is different 1922, has lasted as the suddenly given senior commands as majors, colonels even. N'T be settled here after Truman were all dedicated Cold Warriors not there anymore Communism was doomed from first. Unappealing political system, most likely in a situation too like 1919 for comfort world remaining! Have spread through the media, government, Hollywood, the best way to gain control and influence another.